A mortgage application asks for your race, your ethnicity and your sex, and then tells you the lender isn't allowed to use the answers. That's not a contradiction; it's two federal laws working at once. One requires the question so regulators can detect discrimination in the data. The other makes acting on the answer illegal.
This is what those laws give you, in practical terms, and what to do if you think a lender or an appraiser broke them.
The two laws
The Fair Housing Act covers anything to do with housing, including mortgage lending, and protects seven classes: race, color, religion, national origin, sex, familial status (having children under 18, or being pregnant) and disability.
The Equal Credit Opportunity Act covers all credit, mortgages included, and adds marital status, age, receipt of public-assistance income, and exercising your rights under consumer-credit laws (disputing a bill, say).
Between them, a lender may not, on any of those grounds: refuse your application, offer you different terms or a different rate, discourage you from applying, steer you toward or away from a loan or a neighborhood, or let the appraisal be influenced. Redlining, treating a neighborhood differently because of the race or national origin of the people who live there, is illegal.
One note on a moving target. In September 2025 HUD withdrew its 2021 policy of accepting complaints of sexual-orientation and gender-identity discrimination under "sex." Many state and local laws still cover both, and courts continue to interpret the federal statute. If it applies to you, a state or local fair-housing agency may be the stronger route.
What they can ask, and what they can't
- Marital status: on a mortgage, a lender may ask, but only "married, unmarried or separated." Not whether you're divorced, widowed or planning to marry.
- Children: a lender may not ask about birth-control practices or whether you plan to have children. It may ask how many dependents you have, because that affects expenses.
- Income: a lender may not discount or refuse to consider part-time income, child support, alimony or public assistance because of what it is. It has to evaluate whether each is reliable, the same way it would a salary. (You can choose not to disclose alimony or child support unless you want it counted.)
- Race, ethnicity and sex: the lender is required by the Home Mortgage Disclosure Act to ask, and to report your answers, without your name, in a public dataset regulators use to spot patterns. You can decline. If you decline in person, the lender records its own observation. Either way, the answer may not be used to decide your loan.
The notices and documents you're owed
Under ECOA's Regulation B, a lender must:
- Tell you its decision within 30 days of a complete application.
- Give you the specific reasons for a denial, a counteroffer or a worse-than-requested approval (an "adverse action notice"), or tell you that you can request them within 60 days. "Did not meet our standards" is not a reason; "debt-to-income ratio too high" is.
- Give you a free copy of every appraisal or valuation used in the decision, promptly when it's done and no later than three business days before closing. You can waive the timing, not the copy. You may be charged for the appraisal itself, never for the copy.
Keep the adverse action notice. Vague reasons, or reasons that don't match your file, are the starting point for a complaint.
When the appraisal looks wrong
Appraisal bias, lower values in minority neighborhoods or for minority owners, has been documented in federal studies, and it costs real money at purchase and especially at refinance.
Your first tool is a reconsideration of value (ROV). Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac require lenders to have an ROV process and to tell you about it when they deliver the appraisal. You submit specific objections: comparable sales the appraiser missed, factual errors about the property, or language in the report that shouldn't be there. The lender forwards it to the appraiser, who must respond. Be concrete: "the appraiser used three comps from across the highway and ignored two closer sales at higher prices" works; "the value is too low" doesn't. (FHA dropped its separate borrower-ROV rule in March 2025, but FHA lenders still handle reconsiderations.)
If you believe the appraisal was discriminatory, not just mistaken, you can report it to HUD, the CFPB, the Appraisal Subcommittee's national complaint hotline, and your state appraiser licensing board, which disciplines individual appraisers. More on handling a value gap in appraised value vs purchase price.
How to file a complaint
What happens after you file with HUD
Before filing: you have one year from the act, and it's free
- Day 0
File online at hud.gov/fairhousing, by phone at 800-669-9777, or with a state or local fair-housing agency. No lawyer or proof required; a specific account of what happened is enough.
- Days 1 to 10
HUD acknowledges the complaint, notifies the lender, and may refer the case to a state or local agency with equivalent law.
Investigation: HUD's target is 100 days, often missed
- Throughout
Conciliation is offered at any point: a negotiated settlement that can include money, a corrected loan, or policy changes.
- About day 100
Finding. Reasonable cause leads to a charge, heard by an administrative law judge or, if either side elects, in federal court with government attorneys. No cause ends the HUD case, not your rights.
- Up to 2 years
Private lawsuit. Separately from HUD, you can sue in federal court within two years of the act, for damages, attorney's fees and injunctions.
HUD's fair-housing office lost substantial staff in 2025 and has acknowledged a backlog; local fair-housing centers and state agencies handle most complaints and are often faster. A complaint to the CFPB (consumerfinance.gov/complaint) runs in parallel for lending issues.
Three places take complaints, and you don't have to pick just one: HUD (or your state or local fair-housing agency) for Fair Housing Act violations, the CFPB for lending violations under either law, and the Department of Justice for patterns affecting many people. Testing organizations, nonprofits that send matched applicants to the same lender, can also investigate on your behalf.
What a violation looks like in practice
Discrimination in lending today is rarely a refusal. It looks like a quote that's a quarter point higher than the one your coworker got the same week, a loan officer who steers you toward an FHA loan when you qualify for conventional, a "we don't lend much in that area," an appraisal that ignores the sales on your side of the street, or an application that simply stalls. The protection against all of them is the same: shop two or three lenders, keep every Loan Estimate, and compare them line by line with the Loan Estimate comparator. Different terms for the same borrower profile is the evidence.
The move
Know the two lists of protected classes, keep your adverse action notices and appraisal copies, and use the ROV process the moment an appraisal looks off. If something feels wrong, write down the date, the person and the words, and file within the year. You don't need proof to start; you need a specific account.
Federal fair-lending rules and HUD's enforcement policies changed in 2025 and 2026 and may change again; some protections also depend on state and local law. This is general information, not legal advice. For your situation, contact a fair-housing agency or an attorney.