Skip to content

Avg. locked rates

Costs, fees & credit

Which debts count in your DTI (and the 10-payment rule that can flip an approval)

On this page

Costs, fees & credit

A row of discs, most filled and one struck through: the debts that count and the one that doesn't.

Not every bill counts against you. The debts lenders include, the ones they ignore, how student loans are figured by program, and why paying off one car loan can turn a denial into an approval.

Your debt-to-income ratio is the number most likely to decide your mortgage, and most people assume it includes everything they pay each month. It doesn't. Lenders count the debts that show up on your credit report or your application and that will keep going after closing. Rent, utilities, phone bills, insurance, childcare and groceries don't count, even though they shape your real budget.

That leaves a specific list, with specific rules for each line. A few of those rules can change your answer by more than a raise would.

What always counts

  • Installment loans with more than 10 payments left: car loans, personal loans, furniture financing, buy-now-pay-later plans that report.
  • Revolving accounts: the minimum payment on each credit card and line of credit. If the report shows no minimum, lenders use 5% of the balance.
  • Student loans, by a formula that depends on the program (below).
  • Lease payments, always, no matter how few months remain. A lender assumes you'll lease again.
  • Court-ordered payments: child support and alimony with more than 10 months to run. (Conventional lenders may subtract alimony from your income instead of adding it to your debts, which produces a slightly better ratio.)
  • Other mortgages you'll keep, with their taxes, insurance and dues.

What doesn't count, or can be excluded

  • Installment debts with 10 or fewer payments left. The 10-payment rule, below.
  • Debts someone else pays. A loan you co-signed, or a debt a family member pays for you, can be left out if you show 12 months of payments made from the other person's account. Same for business debts paid by your business.
  • 401(k) loans and loans secured by your own savings. You're borrowing from yourself.
  • Medical collections. FHA, VA and USDA exclude them from their collection tests; Fannie Mae's automated system doesn't require them paid. See medical debt and your mortgage.
  • Collections on a one-unit primary residence under Fannie Mae's automated underwriting, whatever the balance. FHA is stricter: non-medical collections totaling $2,000 or more must be paid, put on a plan, or counted at 5% of the balance each month.
  • Utilities, insurance, phone plans, subscriptions, childcare. Real costs, not "debts."

Judgments are the exception to everything. An unpaid court judgment generally has to be paid at or before closing, or on a documented payment plan with a few months of history, in every program.

The 10-payment rule

An installment loan with 10 or fewer monthly payments remaining can usually be dropped from your DTI. The idea is simple: a debt that disappears within the first year of the mortgage isn't a long-term burden.

Each program words it a little differently:

  • Fannie Mae: excluded, unless the payment "significantly affects" your ability to pay. The underwriter decides. There's no percentage test.
  • Freddie Mac: the same 10-month line, applied more mechanically by its automated system.
  • FHA and USDA: excluded only if the loan ends within 10 months and all such payments together are 5% or less of your gross monthly income.
  • VA: excluded if the payment won't have a "severe impact" on your finances.

The counterintuitive part is what this means for a loan that's just past the line. A car payment of $520 with 14 months remaining counts in full. Pay four months ahead and it has 10 left, and it may disappear from the ratio. But FHA and USDA specifically prohibit paying a loan down to get under 10 months, and Fannie Mae says such paydowns must be "carefully evaluated." Paying the loan off is different, and allowed everywhere. The question is whether that's the best use of the cash.

A worked example

One paid-off car loan, two different answers
Monthly figureBeforeAfter paying off the car
Gross income$6,800$6,800
Proposed housing payment (PITIA)$2,150$2,150
Car loan (balance $7,900, 16 payments left)$520$0
Student loans$310$310
Credit-card minimums$110$110
Total debt counted$3,090$2,570
Back-end DTI45.4%37.8%

Hypothetical example, not a quote or offer of credit. At 45.4% this file is over FHA's base manual limit of 43% and Freddie Mac's 45% manual cap; at 37.8% it clears the FHA, VA and USDA manual limits and sits well inside the automated limits for conventional loans. The $7,900 payoff bought that.

Before you write that check, weigh it against the down payment and the reserves you'd be giving up. Draining savings to fix a ratio can create a different problem: see reserves vs. an emergency fund.

Student loans, by program

Student loans are where the programs differ most, and where a borrower on an income-driven plan can see wildly different DTIs from one lender to the next.

How each program figures a student-loan payment
ProgramPayment used in the DTI
Fannie MaeThe payment on the credit report, or a documented plan payment. A documented $0 income-driven payment counts as $0. Deferred or in forbearance: 1% of the balance, or a fully amortizing payment you document.
Freddie MacThe reported payment if above zero; if $0, 0.5% of the balance. A $0 plan payment is not accepted.
FHAThe reported or documented payment if above zero; if $0, 0.5% of the balance. Excluded only if forgiven, cancelled or paid in full.
VACounted unless deferred at least 12 months past closing. The greater of the reported payment or 5% of the balance ÷ 12, unless a plan payment is documented to continue 12+ months.
USDAThe reported or documented payment if above zero; if $0, 0.5% of the balance.

On a $60,000 balance with a $0 income-driven payment, Fannie Mae counts $0; Freddie Mac, FHA and USDA count $300; VA counts $250. Same borrower, four answers.

If you're on an income-driven plan, ask any lender which program they're pricing you into and what payment they're using. If the answer is "0.5% of the balance" and your plan payment is documented and small, a conventional loan through Fannie Mae's system may qualify you when the others won't. More in how student loans affect qualifying.

Paying off debt to qualify

You can pay a credit card to zero at or before closing and have the payment removed, and in every program the account doesn't have to be closed (keeping it open is better for your score). The payoff has to show on the Closing Disclosure or a statement, and the money has to come from assets the lender already verified. Installment loans can be paid off entirely; just not paid down to the 10-month line on FHA or USDA.

What you can't do is make the debt disappear by moving it. A balance transfer, a new personal loan to consolidate cards, or a family loan to pay off a car all show up again, either on the report or in your bank statements. Lenders re-pull credit before closing.

The move

List every debt that will survive closing, then sort it: more than 10 payments left, 10 or fewer, paid by someone else, student loans. Run the DTI calculator with only the ones that count. If you're near a program's line, the cheapest fix is usually a single installment loan close to the end of its life, paid off outright, after you've confirmed the payoff won't leave you short on down payment or reserves.


Debt-treatment rules differ by program and lender and change over time. Confirm how your lender will count each debt before you pay anything off to qualify.

Jahno is free and reader-supported. If this guide helped, you can chip in — a thank-you is plenty too.

About the author

Mike Jaghnoun is a mortgage loan originator, NMLS ID #1262992 (licenses inactive). Jahno is his independent publication on mortgage education — written from the borrower's side. It's educational only and doesn't offer loans. More about Mike and how Jahno works.

The newsletter

One email when a new piece is published.

No marketing sequences, no upsells, no list-building tricks.

Your address is used only for this; see our privacy policy.